When to use a line reactor on VFD?

Tagged: ,

This topic contains 3 replies, has 3 voices, and was last updated by Chris Niel Chris Niel 6 months ago.

Viewing 4 posts - 1 through 4 (of 4 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #886
    Chris Niel
    Chris Niel
    Participant
    Karma Points: 11
    Rank: Padawan

    Probably a dumb question but should line reactors be used when supplying 3 phase power to VFD’s? What exactly do they do?

    #887
    Matt Dekker
    fleeter1
    Moderator
    Karma Points: 101
    Rank: Jedi

    As far as I know they are only used to ensure a clean power supply from the Utility to the VFD. If you are installing a drive in a plant where there are very large power consumption changes happening frequently it may be a good idea to use a line reactor to protect the drive from other equipment in the plant that may cause nuisance drive faults or even trips. Most VFD spec’s call for or recommend a line reactor be installed with the VFD but if they were that important would they not integrate them into the drive itself?? The drive manufacturers that I have dealt with still warrant VFD’s that are not protected by line reactors but they do try and falsely accuse infrequent drive trips on not having a clean power source. The biggest problems I normally have with using line reactors is the increased panel space required (or external location) and the cost which is normally about 1/4 the cost of the drive itself.
    I use the following criteria when determining whether or not to install reactors:
    New or existing installation? New install panel can be designed to accommodate the reactors, existing may or may not have room for them.
    How critical is the application? Can you afford down time, are you running them 24/7 where they might trip at 3AM in a power surge or brown-out condition that no-one is around to witness. Is there a back up system? Do you have a spare drive on hand? Are there several drives from the same power source or something to prove it is not bad power causing trips.
    Do you have the extra cash to purchase the reactors?
    My personal opinion is that they are definitely not required for every application and seem to be a bit of a scapegoat and money grab item and in applications under 20HP, they are typically not required.
    On a side note, if you are putting a drive on an existing application, I would be much more concerned on the motor you are applying the drive to. Is it inverter rated? What is the minimum speed the existing motor / load can handle. Self cooled motors and pumps can not always take being run for a long time at slow speeds.
    Hope this helps!

    #888

    Fleeter1 made some valid points, however, here is when I would recommend the use of a line reactor, particularly on new installations:

    1. As fleeter1 mentioned, if the input line power is prone to have disturbances such as surges, spikes, transients, etc.
    2. When the supply line power is very stiff (greater than 10 times the kVA rating of the connected VFD) – to minimize damage to the drive under supply transformer faults.
    3. When harmonic distortion is a concern – an input line reactor reduces harmonics that the VFD generates back onto the line.

    3% impedance line reactors can be used to reduce power line transient voltages caused by capacitor switching, line notching, DC Bus over-voltage tripping and inverter over-current and over-voltage conditions. They improve input power factor and reduce cross-talk between drives.

    5% impedance line reactors have the same benefits plus provide maximum harmonic reduction without added capacitance. The harmonic signals generated by the VFD could produce distortion levels that may not be acceptable for high frequency or noise sensitive equipment.

    My two cents!

    #890
    Chris Niel
    Chris Niel
    Participant
    Karma Points: 11
    Rank: Padawan

    Hey thanks guys! This is a new installation so to play it safe it’s probably a good idea to just design it in. Great looking site by the way!

Viewing 4 posts - 1 through 4 (of 4 total)

You must be logged in to reply to this topic.